New York is known for its diverse food scene, and steak restaurants are a big part of that. I’ve tried many spots across the city to find where you can get quality cuts cooked just right. Whether you like your steak simple or with unique flavors, the city offers plenty of options.
Choosing the best steak restaurant means looking at taste, atmosphere, and value. I focused on places that deliver a great dining experience with consistently good steaks. This list will help you find where to enjoy a solid steak meal in New York without guessing.
1) STK Steakhouse
I recently visited STK Steakhouse in Midtown, and it combines a modern steakhouse with a stylish lounge. The atmosphere is lively, with DJs playing music that creates a great vibe for dining or relaxing with drinks.
The menu focuses on prime cuts of steak and fresh seafood. I found the quality of the food consistent with what you’d expect at a fine dining restaurant, and the presentation was clean and attractive. The portion sizes were just right, not too big or too small.
They offer a large space for private events, with room for both seated dinners and cocktail parties. I heard from the staff that lunch starts at about $45, and dinner can go up to $95 per person, which matches the premium quality of the experience.
The service was efficient, and the staff seemed well-trained and attentive. STK feels like a good spot for both a fun night out and a special occasion, thanks to the mix of dining and lounge areas.
Rating: 4.8 (30,761 reviews)
Location: 1114 6th Ave, New York, NY 10036
Contact: (646) 624-2455
Website: Visit Website
2) Keens Steakhouse
When I walked into Keens Steakhouse, the first thing that struck me was the old, wood-paneled rooms. The place feels like stepping back in time. It has a classic, clubby atmosphere that makes it great for a relaxed dinner.
The steaks are big and cooked just right. Their mutton chops stood out to me, something you don’t see often at other steakhouses. The flavors were rich and the portions generous, which made the meal very satisfying.
Keens has a long history, dating back to 1885. It used to be a popular spot for actors and writers nearby, and you can still feel that old New York charm. I also enjoyed their happy hour, especially the unique bloody Mary with balsamic vinegar.
The staff was attentive but not intrusive, which added to the easy-going vibe. It’s a good place to go if you want a mix of great food and a dining experience with some history.
Rating: 4.6 (8809 reviews)
Location: 72 W 36th St., New York, NY 10018
Contact: (212) 947-3636
Website: Visit Website
3) Gallaghers Steakhouse
When I walked into Gallaghers Steakhouse, I immediately noticed the classic New York steakhouse vibe. The red banquettes and walls covered with photos of famous people give the place a rich history feel. It’s clear this spot has been serving steaks for decades and still honors its past.
I ordered the ribeye cooked over hickory coals. The steak was juicy and full of flavor, just as I expected from a restaurant with such a strong reputation. The staff knew the menu well and offered great recommendations, which made the meal even better.
The location is perfect if you want to experience the energy of Midtown Manhattan. It’s near Broadway and Times Square, so it’s great for a meal before or after a show. The atmosphere is busy but not rushed, allowing you to enjoy your steak and soak in the old-school charm.
Rating: 4.6 (7957 reviews)
Location: 228 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 586-5000
Website: Visit Website
4) Empire Steak House Times Square
When I visited Empire Steak House Times Square, I noticed its lively atmosphere right in the heart of the city. The place feels upscale but still comfortable. It’s a good spot if you want classic steak paired with a solid wine list.
The steak was cooked just how I asked, juicy and tender with a nice sear. Besides steak, they offer seafood and other dishes that add variety if you’re dining with a group. The service was attentive without being pushy, making the experience smooth.
The setting works well for both casual dinners and special events. I saw a few groups celebrating, which shows the place can handle different occasions well. Overall, it’s a dependable choice for steak lovers near Times Square.
Rating: 4.9 (3713 reviews)
Location: 233 W 49th St, New York, NY 10019
Contact: (212) 355-5542
Website: Visit Website
5) COTE Korean Steakhouse
When I visited COTE Korean Steakhouse, the first thing that stood out was the energy of the place. It mixes the fun, hands-on vibe of Korean barbecue with the style of a classic American steakhouse. The tables have built-in smokeless grills, so you get to cook your own high-quality meat right at the table.
The beef here is impressive. Everything served is USDA Prime or better, including American Wagyu. The cuts are tender and rich, and the grilling brings out deep flavors. The staff is skilled and offers great advice on cooking times and pairing options.
COTE also has an extensive wine list with over 1,200 options. I found the wine choices balanced well with the bold flavors of the meat. Cocktails are creative but comfortable, matching the overall experience. Though they don’t take reservations, arriving early helped me avoid a long wait.
Rating: 4.6 (3655 reviews)
Location: 16 W 22nd St, New York, NY 10010
Contact: (212) 401-7886
Website: Visit Website
Frequently Asked Questions
I gathered details on the best steakhouses in New York City, focusing on Michelin stars, ratings, history, popularity, and steak quality. This information highlights some well-known spots and what makes them stand out.
Which New York City steakhouses have earned a Michelin star?
Some New York steakhouses have Michelin stars, but it changes yearly. COTE Korean Steakhouse is known to have earned a Michelin star for its high-quality steaks and unique Korean style.
What are the top-rated steakhouses in Manhattan according to Zagat?
Zagat often rates classic and trendy steakhouses highly. Places like Keens Steakhouse and Gallaghers Steakhouse usually score well for their atmosphere and steak quality in Manhattan.
What is the oldest steakhouse that you can dine at in New York City?
Keens Steakhouse is one of the oldest steakhouses in New York. It opened in 1885 and is famous for its historic charm and traditional steaks.
Can you list some of the most famous steakhouses in New York City?
Some of the most famous steakhouses include Keens Steakhouse, Gallaghers Steakhouse, Empire Steak House Times Square, STK Steakhouse, and COTE Korean Steakhouse.
Which steakhouse in New York City is considered the number one chain in America?
Empire Steak House Times Square is part of a well-known chain and is often recognized as a top steakhouse chain in America.
What are some steakhouses in NYC with the best quality steaks for dining?
STK Steakhouse and COTE Korean Steakhouse are known for high-quality steaks and modern dining experiences. Keens and Gallaghers also offer excellent steaks with a classic touch. You can find strong recommendations and reviews for these places online, like on TripAdvisor.
